Happy Columbus Day, y’all.
So why the fuss about abolishing a national holiday dedicated to one of the greatest explorers in history? The man who conclusively proved wrong to many naysayers who generally assumed the world was really flat and that there was nothing but dark abyss at the world’s edge. He did not only set to prove them wrong but to demonstrate that by following the sun, the stars and trailing the trade winds on the sea going westward, he could reach the West Indies Islands on the other side of the world (where southeast Asia is located). He did not expect strange new lands and peoples to be in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean along the way. He mistakenly thought he had reached the shores of the long-lost Atlantis (he landed on the shores of San Salvador).
Most disappointedly, the city of Columbus has choose not to celebrate the day for its namesake, preferably to slink away and pretend that there’s no Columbus Day to celebrate, treating it as an Italian-American community thing (not really, Columbus’ day has long been celebrated since the colonial days). I say that’s wrong. Sure, he had faults (who else isn’t?) but to pass 21st century judgment on a 16th century explorer is sadly pathetic and ridiculous. Political-religious circumstances and pressures of the 15th to 16th century Old World were very different, enormously difficult and bloody. There were little scientific and medicinal standards of the time, and much of the peoples lived in general ignorance buoyed by religious and social concepts of the world they knew and lived in. Further, it was a especially difficult period for Christoffa Corombo (his original Genoese name) trying to raise money and support for his West Indies navigation voyage. He was repeatedly turned down by few monarchies around Europe, even the King and Queen of Spain. The latter monarchy changed its mind, funded and supported him for the great sea voyage west, notwithstanding their doubts of its success.
Modern critics of Columbus tended to focus on the very negative aspects of his exploration history of the new world, their sensibilities offended by Columbus’ cruelty to the natives and their subsequent enslavement. What they overlooked the facts that Columbus was under enormous pressures to deliver the riches to the Spanish monarchy who were paying him generous sums and expected a return of investments from him. His crews were more or less mutinous toward him, their lives depended on his navigation and leadership skills. Worse, few threatened to kill him. If he doesn’t deliver on promises and returns, he would risk losing support for future voyages of the new world. And remember, as soon after he returned to Spain from his first voyage, words got spread out to Europe of Columbus’ discovery of the new world, other explorers and monarchies would soon get on their own voyages and compete against Columbus and Spain, respectively. As vanity and ego were the norm of that time, Columbus couldn’t risk losing his fame and fortunes in the process and neither could Spain lose such a grand opportunity.
Like I said, there were little scientific and medicinal standards in the 15/16th century Europe, though it was the beginning of that modern standards. Peoples lived and died under all sort of circumstances throughout the human history. Peoples died of various diseases brought about by warfare, famine, poor treatments, or sheer stupidity. To blame Columbus for all the wrongs and faults for his pioneer explorations, as his critics repeatedly pounded on, is futile and a waste of time. Do you wanted to go on living in perpetual ignorance of how other peoples of long ago lived their lives much different than what it is like for us today and feign outrage at how they were treated long ago?
Different circumstances, different times, people! You can not be stuck feeling guilty in the 21th century just because what other peoples did to others in the 16th century? So what, move on! We learned what happened in these times and places, whether it was painfully interesting or horribly tragic, happened a long time ago. We can only hope and learn not to repeat such tragic events.
For those who still pound on Columbus’ enslavement of the new world’s natives, how about looking into the long history of the Muslim Arabs conquering half of Africa, began the enslavement and forced conversion of the black Africans, and started the vast slave trade? Prepare to be shocked and outraged, since your history teachers didn’t tell you about that? The Arabic word for the black is the same as the Arabic word for slave: “abed”. What a wonderful “religion” Islam is. *eyes rolled*
Debbie Schlussel has a nice blog about Columbus’ day and pointing out a fascinating blog about Columbus probably being a Jew. I agreed with her on this:
Columbus shouldn’t just be a celebratory figure in the Italian-American community. He’s someone all of us who live in America should celebrate. He helped open the West to us all.
I hope the “progressive” liberals don’t even dare to rename the city of Columbus just to appease the silly sensibilities of the PC-obsessed left. The people of Columbus would arrive in pitchforks and calling for their heads.
One last thing: my great-grandfather (on my father’s mother’s side of the family) was a Knight of Columbus, being the son of the Scottish/Irish Catholic immigrants and one of the founders of Santa Cruz, California. The Knights of Columbus, still active today, is a large Catholic fraternal organization for the American Catholics whose immigrant forebears came to America for new opportunities and new life but endured discrimination by anti-Catholic sentiments and the lack of social services for the Catholic immigrants from Ireland and Europe.
Happy Columbus Day.
And Happy Thanksgiving to the Canadians up north of USA.
Update: Here’s the book that does refute all the smears, stupid criticism and futile hatred upon Christopher Columbus: The Enemies of Christopher Columbus by Thomas A. Bowden. Check it out.