Finally, a rational, free-thinking Muslim from Saudi Arabia? Dr. Ibrahim al-Buleihi, a liberal Muslim reformist and thinker, aptly declared that Western Civilization has actually liberated mankind from the shackles of backwardness and criticized his own country’s cultural backwardness and dysfunctional tribal ways. I don’t know much about this man or his background, but I believe he may be his country’s best hope for the Arabs and Muslims, especially if he hopes to try to change their hostile attitudes toward Western Civilization and America. Read it all: Western Civilization Has Liberated Mankind.
Excerpt:
‘Okaz:“This may be so, and I’m with you in this demand but, sir, would you summarize for us the reason for your admiration of Western culture, so that we can have a basis for discussion?”
Buleihi: “There is no one reason, there are a thousand reasons, which all induce me to admire the West and emphasize its absolute excellence in all matters of life. Western civilization is the only civilization that liberated man from his illusions and shackles; it recognized his individuality and provided him with capabilities and opportunities to cultivate himself and realize his aspirations. [Western civilization] humanized political authority and established mechanisms to guarantee relative equality and relative justice and to prevent injustice and to alleviate aggression. This does not mean that this is a flawless civilization; indeed, it is full of deficiencies. (editor’s note: of course, what other civilization doesn’t have them?) Yet it is the greatest which man has achieved throughout history. [Before the advent of Western civilization,] humanity was in the shackles of tyranny, impotence, poverty, injustice, disease, and wretchedness.
“It is an extraordinary civilization, and it is not an extension of any ancient civilization, with the exception of Greek civilization, which is the source of contemporary civilization. I have completed a book on this great extraordinary civilizational leap, titled The Qualitative Changes in Human Civilization. Western civilization is its own product and it is not indebted to any previous civilization except for the Greek one … It has revived the Greek achievements in the fields of philosophy, science, literature, politics, society, human dignity, and veneration of reason, while recognizing its shortcomings and illusions and stressing its continuous need for criticism, review and correction.”
Even so, al-Buleihi declared himself a Muslim first and a liberal second, putting the Islamic religious principles as his foundation to promote liberal actions in a society, that he believes only through Islam it can be achieved. I digress, however, and I clearly draw the line in allowing a religion, less alone Islam, to mandate and dictate liberal actions in a society. Individual achievements and liberal actions can be made without any religion or religious guidance involved necessarily. Thomas Edison was not motivated or prompted by any religious principle to invent a light bulb and bring electric light to the masses, for example. Nevertheless, in this AAFAQ site, Dr. al-Buleihi put forth his concerns about his fellow Arabs and Muslims being perpetually mired in the dominant but dysfunctional tribal-cultural ways of his country, that which, he noted, are hampering their real developments to aspire and achieve themselves individually within a closed religious society, whether in Saudi Arabia, Iran, UAE, Afghanistan or any other Islamic country:
“Humans are originally individuals, but cultures (including Arab culture) have dissolved the individual in the tribe, sect or state, so that the individual was unable to know his own identity and recover it, except with the diffusion of philosophical ideas from Greece, where, in the fifth century BC, philosophy produced elevated human values for the first time in human history, and the human being became an individual of value for himself and the ultimate goal, and not merely a means for others. (editor’s note: this is the most cherished belief of the Western civilization, which has formed the basis of individual liberty ever since. You are always your own person, never for others.)
“Regarding the current situation of Arabs and Muslims, Al-Buleihi says: ”I believe that the situation of the Arabs and Muslims is very bad. The reason is the closed culture and its inability to absorb modern civilization, to be aware of its shortcomings, and to be aware of the merits of other cultures.”
Even surprising to me is Dr. al-Buleihi’s acknowledgment that the whole world, most especially in western democratic nations, is regressing to the Muslim ways and restricting individual liberties by changing some laws, that is something I have acknowledged for so long: that Western political correctism and government pandering to the Muslims, in this age of Islamic terrorism and fundamentalism, are undoing all of the greatest achievements and liberties of the Western Civilization in the process. As a westerner and American, we cannot keep doing this just to pander and appease the Islamic world for long:
To those who contend that his prescriptions are too harsh and would frustration to those receiving them he answers that his “… views are not frustrating … but the real frustration is that we praise ourselves while we are in an terrible situation, and the Arabs and Muslims have become a joke to the rest of the world. That is, we are a joke, and no one is concerned with us. But now we announce that we innovate in cutting off heads, in killing, in bombings — that is the extent to which we can innovate. This is a major problem, I mean, that we are a burden not only to ourselves but to the whole world. I believe that the whole world is regressing because of our actions. For example, the countries of the West — democratic countries like America, Europe, Britain and others — have changed their laws in ways that restrict liberties. Transportation has become slow because … people have to stand in long queues to fly on an airplane, due to searches, something that was previously unknown. We have become a burden to ourselves, and to the world.”
Exactly! What the Islamic world needed is a “Martin Luther nailing the 95 Theses (or more)” to the gates of Mecca, criticizing the dangerous excesses of Islam and condemning a large body of repressive rulers, mullahs, imams, clerics and followers for trying to impose Islam upon the world and peoples in the most unethical, dangerous and improper ways, even legal and “benign” ways, too! They cannot continue to follow the ways of the 7th century world and apply them in the 21st century world, thus expecting everyone to respect and conform to them. No way, not now, not ever. The world cannot be belong to Islam or any other religion in any shape or form. That being said, it is absolutely unacceptable for us to forsake our Western civilization, its great humanist achievements and individual liberties for the benefits of other civilizations still mired in the old ways and religious/cultural backwardness. For example, honor killing is still a way of life in the Islamic countries and, until recently, it’s being introduced into Western, democratic nations. It should be banned worldwide.
We may look forward to this Dr. Ibrahim al-Buleihi and his thoughts in the near future, if he is not being harassed, intimidated or killed by the backward practitioners of Islam so far. Here’s hope aspiring in the backward parts of the world and look to the Western civilization for inspiration and ideas.